GERTLER LAW FIRM

CALL FOR A FREE CONSULT

504.581.6411
877.581.6411
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About the firm
    • Judge David Gertler
    • Attorney Louis Gertler
    • Attorney Mike Gertler
    • Attorney Josh Gertler
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury & Accidents
          • Auto & Transportation Accidents
            • Car Accidents
            • Truck / 18-Wheeler Accidents
            • Motorcycle Accidents
            • Pedestrian Accidents
            • Uber / Lyft Accidents
            • Drunk Driving Accidents
            • Street Car / Public Transit Accidents
          • Slip & Fall / Premises Accidents
          • Dog Bites / Animal Attacks
          • Construction Accidents
          • Brain & Catastrophic Injuries
          • Wrongful Death
    • Product Liability & Mass Torts / Class Actions
          • Defective Products
          • Device / Implant Recall Claims
            • Defective Hip / Hip Replacement
            • Knee Replacement Recall
            • Shoulder Pain Pumps
            • Paragard IUD
          • Environmental / Toxic Exposure / Cancer
            • Mesothelioma / Asbestos
            • Roundup or similar herbicide / toxin claims
          • Class Action & Mass Torts
    • Medical Malpractice & Medical Injuries
          • Medical Malpractice
          • Birth Injuries
          • Dental Malpractice
          • Brain Injury
    • Elder Abuse & Premises Liability
          • Nursing Home Abuse / Neglect
          • Premises Liability
    • Wills, Successions & Estate Services
          • Louisiana Successions
          • Wills
  • Case Results
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us

Home » Does Someone Else Paying My Medical Expenses Hurt My Personal Injury Lawsuit?

Does Someone Else Paying My Medical Expenses Hurt My Personal Injury Lawsuit?

October 29, 2012 by Louis Gertler Last Modified: October 28, 2025

In most New Orleans personal injury cases, the injured person does not rely solely on a case’s outcome to pay for expenses from the injuries. It is common for other individuals or organizations to pay some of the expenses for the injuries claimed in a personal injury lawsuit. These other parties are called collateral sources. Examples of collateral sources include health insurers, an employer who continues to pay lost wages, or even a family member who pays medical bills.

The general rule under Louisiana law is that payments made by collateral sources do not reduce the victim’s recovery in a personal injury lawsuit. For example, if the victim’s employer pays for some medical expenses, the victim may still pursue medical expenses in the lawsuit. There are, however, exceptions to this rule based on the specific facts surrounding a payment. These exceptions include whether the plaintiff provided some consideration, such as an enrollment fee, for the benefit. Collateral source benefits for which the victim paid no consideration may not be recoverable.

Also, in some cases, an insurer who paid the collateral source benefits, not the injured person, may be the proper plaintiff to pursue compensation from the defendant.

Evidence of payments made by a collateral source is not admissible in a personal injury lawsuit. As a result, a defendant cannot argue to a jury that the damages awarded to a victim should be reduced because some of the victim’s expenses from the injury have already been paid.

The attorneys at The Gertler Law Firm have years of experience, if you have been injured and have any questions regarding how collateral source payments may impact a personal injury lawsuit, please feel free to call our office at (504) 581-6411 for free consultation.

About Louis Gertler

Louis L. Gertler, Esq. is a New Orleans attorney and partner at Gertler Law Firm. He represents individuals and families in civil matters involving serious injuries and wrongful death in Louisiana, including claims related to product incidents, medical care, and large-scale proceedings such as mass tort matters and class actions.

Louis earned his Juris Doctor from Tulane University Law School in 1994. He has been listed in The Best Lawyers in America since 2012 and was named Lawyer of the Year for Product Liability Litigation Plaintiffs in New Orleans in 2022, an honor based on peer review.

Louis approaches each matter with thorough preparation, careful review of the facts, and clear communication, helping clients understand the process and available options at each stage of the case.

Primary Sidebar

Search Our Site

Practice Areas

PERSONAL INJURY & ACCIDENTS

  • Auto & Transportation Accidents
    • Car Accidents
    • Truck / 18-Wheeler Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Uber / Lyft Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Accidents
    • Street Car / Public Transit Accidents
  • Slip & Fall / Premises Accidents
  • Dog Bites / Animal Attacks
  • Construction Accidents
  • Brain & Catastrophic Injuries
  • Wrongful Death

PRODUCT LIABILITY & MASS TORTS / CLASS ACTIONS

  • Defective Products
  • Device / Implant Recall Claims
    • Defective Hip / Hip Replacement
    • Knee Replacement Recall
    • Shoulder Pain Pumps
    • Paragard IUD
  • Environmental / Toxic Exposure / Cancer
    • Mesothelioma / Asbestos
    • Roundup or similar herbicide / toxin claims
  • Class Action & Mass Torts

MEDICAL MALPRACTICE & MEDICAL INJURIES

  • Medical Malpractice
  • Birth Injuries
  • Dental Malpractice
  • Brain Injury

ELDER ABUSE & PREMISES LIABILITY

  • Nursing Home Abuse / Neglect
  • Premises Liability

WILLS, SUCCESSIONS & ESTATE SERVICES

  • Louisiana Successions
  • Wills

Contact Our New Orleans Personal Injury Lawyers Today

NEW ORLEANS

935 Gravier Street
Suite 1900
New Orleans, LA 70112

Call: 504-581-6411

New Orleans Law Office Map

Free Consultation

If you or a loved one has been seriously injured, the path to justice starts with one call.
Contact the Gertler Law Firm at (504) 581-6411 or 1-877-581-6411 for a free consultation.
With more than 50 years of proven results, we are ready to fight for you.

AREAS WE SERVE - LOUISIANA

Northshore

Tangipahoa Parish
Hammond

Orleans Parish
New Orleans

Jefferson Parish
Metairie
Kenner
Gretna
Marrero
Harahan
Harvey
Westwego
Avondale
Jefferson

St. Charles Parish
Destrehan
Luling
St. Rose

St. John the Baptist Parish
LaPlace

Plaquemines Parish
Belle Chasse

St. Bernard Parish
Chalmette
Arabi
Meraux

Washington Parish

Bogalusa

St. Tammany Parish
Pearl River
Slidell
Mandeville
Covington
Abita Springs
Madisonville

Bayou Region

Terrebonne Parish
Houma
Lafourche Parish
Thibodaux

East Baton Rouge Parish
Baton Rouge

PERSONAL INJURY & ACCIDENTS

Auto & Transportation Accidents
Car Accidents
Truck / 18-Wheeler Accidents
Motorcycle Accidents
Pedestrian Accidents
Uber / Lyft Accidents
Drunk Driving Accide
Street Car / Public Transit Accidents

Slip & Fall / Premises Accidents
Dog Bites / Animal Attacks
Construction Accidents
Brain & Catastrophic Injuries
Wrongful Death (accident causes)

MEDICAL MALPRACTICE & MEDICAL INJURIES

Medical Malpractice
Birth Injuries
Dental Malpractice
Brain Injury

PRODUCT LIABILITY & MASS TORTS / CLASS ACTIONS

Defective Products
Device / Implant Recall Claims
Defective Hip / Hip Replacement
Knee Replacement Recall
Shoulder Pain Pumps
Paragard IUD
Environmental / Toxic Exposure / Cancer
Mesothelioma / Asbestos
Roundup or similar herbicide / toxin claims
Class Action & Mass Torts

ELDER ABUSE & PREMISES LIABILITY

Nursing Home Abuse / Neglect
Premises Liability

WILLS, SUCCESSIONS & ESTATE SERVICES

Louisiana Successions
Wills

QUICK LINKS

Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Accessibility Statement
Blog

The material on this Personal Injury Website, managed and operated by Gertler Law Firm, is intended for informational purposes only. The material found on this Website is not intended to be, nor should it ever be interpreted as legal advice or opinion, and does not constitute an attorney – client relationship.

Disclaimer: Case results depend upon a variety of factors unique to each case. Indications of past case results do not guarantee or predict a similar result in future cases. Our New Orleans, Louisiana Injury Attorney Referral Program is in accordance with Rule 1.5(e) of the Louisiana Rules of Professional Conduct.

Copyright © 2025, Gertler Law Firm. All Rights Reserved.

  • Home
  • About Us
    • About the firm
    • Judge David Gertler
    • Attorney Louis Gertler
    • Attorney Mike Gertler
    • Attorney Josh Gertler
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury & Accidents
      • Auto & Transportation Accidents
        • Car Accidents
        • Truck / 18-Wheeler Accidents
        • Motorcycle Accidents
        • Pedestrian Accidents
        • Uber / Lyft Accidents
        • Drunk Driving Accidents
        • Street Car / Public Transit Accidents
      • Slip & Fall / Premises Accidents
      • Dog Bites / Animal Attacks
      • Construction Accidents
      • Brain & Catastrophic Injuries
      • Wrongful Death
    • Product Liability & Mass Torts / Class Actions
      • Defective Products
      • Device / Implant Recall Claims
        • Defective Hip / Hip Replacement
        • Knee Replacement Recall
        • Shoulder Pain Pumps
        • Paragard IUD
      • Environmental / Toxic Exposure / Cancer
        • Mesothelioma / Asbestos
        • Roundup or similar herbicide / toxin claims
      • Class Action & Mass Torts
    • Medical Malpractice & Medical Injuries
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Birth Injuries
      • Dental Malpractice
      • Brain Injury
    • Elder Abuse & Premises Liability
      • Nursing Home Abuse / Neglect
      • Premises Liability
    • Wills, Successions & Estate Services
      • Louisiana Successions
      • Wills
  • Case Results
  • Blog
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us